PLATO’S CLOSET MIDDLETOWN

FAQ's 🔍

Got questions? We’ve got answers. From selling to shopping, here’s the quick version.

Contact Us
💸

Sell for Cash

Bring in trendy, gently used styles for teens and young adults. No appointment needed.

🛍️

Shop New Finds Daily

Fresh arrivals hit the floor every day, so the best pieces do not stay long.

🔥

What We Want

We love current styles, athleticwear, denim, sneakers, graphic tees, and other in-demand looks.

Frequently asked questions
What are your hours?

Mon–Sat: 10AM–9PM
Sun: 11AM–7PM
Where are you located?

1421 Route 35 North
Middletown, NJ 07748
How does selling work?

Bring in your gently used, on-trend styles and we’ll review them while you shop. If we’re able to buy, we’ll make you a cash offer on the spot — no waiting, no appointments.
Do I need an appointment?

Nope! We process buys on a walk-in basis.
How many items can I bring?

You can bring up to 2 bins of teen and young adult styles per day.
Just keep in mind we review items based on current style, condition, and what we need in store.
What condition should items be in?

Think like-new:

  • freshly washed
  • no stains, holes, or excessive wear
  • current styles (nothing too outdated)
What don’t you take?

We pass on:

  • kids or adult brands/sizing. (some brands we buy do overlap with women’s like athletic brands, shoes and purses)
  • items with stains, odors, or damage
  • outdated styles
  • undergarments or swimwear (unless new with tags)
  • anything that doesn’t fit our current inventory needs
What are you looking to buy right now?

We’re always buying, but we especially love:

  • trendy everyday pieces
  • athleticwear
  • denim
  • graphic tees
  • sneakers

Think current styles you’d see in-store right now.
What brands do you take?

We carry all your favorite teen and young adult brands — from everyday mall brands to premium labels. If it’s trendy and in demand, we want to see it.

See our fav brands list
How will I get paid?

We pay cash on the spot for the items we’re able to accept. Offers are based on brand, style, condition, and demand.
Can I shop while you look at my items?

Yes — and honestly… you should. 👀
How long does it take?

Buy times can vary depending on how busy we are, but most buys are reviewed within 30 minutes. You’re welcome to shop while we look through your items, or drop them off and come back before the end of the day.